Wes Ellis./ a personal notebook
Technology. Stories. Side projects.
A few things worth writing down.
← Back to Books & Music

Books & Music

121 Songs Later: The Albums Spotify Says I Can't Stop Playing

A vinyl record spinning on a turntable, the tonearm resting on the groove.

Part 1 of the thread Albums on repeat

THE SHORT VERSION4 points
  • Of my 121 all-time top songs, 17 are The East Pointers, a folk trio from Prince Edward Island.
  • Wild Rivers are next with 11, then Eminem with 9, all from one album.
  • Teddy Swims and Imogen Heap, both written into the notes for my own album, have 11 songs between them.
  • Three of the bands near the top all record for the same label, Nettwerk.

Spotify keeps a playlist for me called "Your All-Time Top Songs." It's 121 songs, about six and a half hours, and it's supposed to be my most-played music ever. So I sorted it by artist and album and counted.

The East Pointers, by a mile

Seventeen of the 121 songs are by The East Pointers, including the very first one, "Wintergreen." They're a folk trio from Prince Edward Island, formed in 2014, built around fiddle, banjo and guitar.

The songs come from four places:

Album Year On my list
What We Leave Behind 2017 Two Weeks, 82 Fires, Tanglewood, Pour Over, Miner's Dream
Yours to Break 2019 Wintergreen, Halfway Tree
House of Dreams (EP) 2022 Kayla, For Me; When I Had You; The House of Dreams; Stronger Than You Know; Save Your Lonely
Secret Victory 2015 Secret Victory

The rest are singles: Best Surprise, I Want You, Maritime Moonshine and Feeling of Home.

"Wintergreen" was the lead single off Yours to Break, and the band wrote that record while they were scattered across the world: one member in Australia, one in England and one in Costa Rica. House of Dreams is a seven-song EP, and five of those seven made my list.

Wild Rivers, the runner-up

Eleven songs belong to Wild Rivers, a Toronto trio who formed at Queen's University in Ontario. They spread across almost everything they've put out:

  • Never Better (2024): Cave, Backfire, Anyways I Love You, Dance
  • Sidelines (2022): Bedrock, Stubborn Heart, Amsterdam
  • Wild Rivers (2016): Wandering Child, Speak Too Soon
  • Songs to Break Up To (2020): Thinking 'Bout Love, twice. Once regular, once acoustic.

Never Better was recorded in Joshua Tree with producer Gabe Wax, and it leans more toward pop than their earlier records.

Eminem's one album

Nine songs are Eminem, and every one of them is from the same record, The Death of Slim Shady (Coup de Grâce), which came out in July 2024. It's his twelfth studio album, and the whole thing is built around a fight between Eminem and his Slim Shady alter ego. "Houdini," the lead single, sits at number three on my list. "Trouble" is on there too, and it's forty-one seconds long.

Fiddle folk, Canadian harmonies and then Antichrist. I contain multitudes.

The two that ended up in my own songs

Teddy Swims has seven songs on the list, four of them from his debut album, I've Tried Everything But Therapy (Part 1): Lose Control, The Door, Some Things I'll Never Know and Apple Juice. "Lose Control" came out in June 2023, ahead of the album that September, and turned into one of the biggest songs of 2024.

Imogen Heap has four, and all four are from one album, Ellipse, from 2009: Aha!, Half Life, Earth and Tidal. She produced the whole record herself.

Those two are the ones I didn't need Spotify to tell me about. Both of them are written into the notes for the album I'm making, as part of the sound I'm chasing: big soul vocals, real players, and electronic edges at the breaks.

Note

If you're trying to pin down your own sound, a top-songs list is a decent place to start. It shows what you actually play, not what you'd say if somebody asked.

The rest of the shelf

Everybody else with three songs or more:

Artist Songs Where most of them come from
KPop Demon Hunters soundtrack 6 The soundtrack album
Mimi Webb 5 Amelia
The Strike 4 The Lost Years and two singles
GoldFord 3 Mostly singles
Lake Street Dive 3 Good Together and Obviously
Billianne 3 Crush and Let Me Run, plus a single
Benson Boone 3 Singles and American Heart

The other 46 songs are one-offs and pairs, everything from Van Halen's "Right Now" to Phil Collins closing the whole list out with "In the Air Tonight."

The thing I didn't expect

When I looked up the bands, three of the names kept landing on the same label: The East Pointers, Wild Rivers and The Strike all put records out through Nettwerk. Whoever's signing bands over there, we have similar taste.

If you want to hear what all this listening turns into, my own songs are in the songbook.